When a Picture-Perfect Home Has a Noisy Flaw

From the outside, Emma’s new house looked like a dream. But inside? Every step in her bedroom came with an unexpected soundtrack. Snaps, cracks, and pops echoed through the floor like a haunted xylophone.

 

Emma didn’t move in expecting a fixer-upper. In fact, the builder (who also doubled as the selling agent) promised to have the creaky floor repaired before she even unpacked a box. But six months after closing, the only thing louder than the noise under her feet was the silence from the people who sold it to her.

Builders sometimes make verbal commitments during the sales process that are later forgotten (or outright ignored) once the ink is dry. (iStock)

Promises Made, Then Ignored

Initially, Emma was told a contractor would come out and make it right. And technically, someone did. Two different contractors, actually. But instead of real fixes, they were allegedly instructed to “just put screws through the carpet.” You read that right: screws through the carpet.

 

Luckily, those contractors were honest enough to say, “Nope, this needs more than a quick patch job.” They recommended removing the carpet and properly addressing the flooring underneath.

 

But the builder didn’t follow through. Weeks turned into months, and Emma found herself sleeping in a different room altogether just to avoid the noise. The response from the builder’s team? Sparse. The accountability? Nonexistent.

When Builders Dodge, Who Holds Them Accountable?

Unfortunately, Emma’s story isn’t unique. Builders sometimes make verbal commitments during the sales process that are later forgotten (or outright ignored) once the ink is dry.

 

Whether it’s incomplete work, corner-cutting to save costs, or communication breakdowns, the buyer is often left footing the bill or suffering the consequences.

 

So what can you do if you’re in Emma’s shoes?

  1. Get promises in writing. Verbal assurances are nice, but they won’t help you in a dispute.
  2. Document everything. Save texts, emails, inspection notes, and contractor feedback.
  3. Know your rights. Georgia law requires sellers to disclose material defects, and licensed agents have ethical obligations to represent deals fairly.
  4. Don’t give up. As Emma’s story shows, polite persistence matters. Especially when backed by credible consumer advocacy.

From Cease-and-Desist to Pink Cement: A Small Win, Hard-Fought

After being stonewalled, Emma turned to the TrustDALE investigative team for help. And while the builder initially responded with a “cease communication” letter (yes, really) the team kept the pressure on. Tactfully, consistently, and legally.

 

Ten days later, a surprise twist: the carpet was removed, the squeaky boards replaced, and Emma now has what she gleefully calls her “pink cement floor.” It’s not glamorous, but it’s progress. And most importantly, it’s quiet.

When the carpet was removed and the squeaky boards replaced, Emma’s home was just as she wanted it – quiet. (iStock)

Takeaways for Smart Homebuyers

Whether you're buying a new build or an older home, don’t let aesthetic charm distract from practical problems. If something doesn’t sound or feel right, press for answers early. Because when corners are cut, it’s often the buyer who bleeds.

 

And if you’ve hit a dead end trying to get a fair resolution, don’t go it alone.

 

Need help solving your own consumer headache?